Saturday, December 19, 2009

Arne Duncan and Teacher Education: Still More "Bullshit"


Those who can do, those who can’t teach, and those who can’t teach, teach teachers.

—Anonymous

Teacher education has long been a low status activity, and U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan isn’t making it any better. Lacking any professional preparation himself, Duncan nevertheless confidently asserts that many, if not most, of the nation’s teacher preparation programs are second-rate. He claims that they attract inferior students and weak faculty. He also charges that colleges and universities use them as “cash cows,” bleeding off the revenues they generate.

Politics, Not Logic
There is truth in Duncan's allegations. But at the same time he demands increased rigor in teacher preparation, Duncan also praises alternative “quickie” routes into teaching.

Logic demands that if teacher education lacks rigor, it must be made tougher, not easier. How shall we account for Duncan's illogic? The explanation is that Duncan holds a political office, and naturally prefers politics to logic. So let's forget his observation that: It’s no surprise that studies repeatedly document that the single biggest influence on student achievement is the quality of the teacher standing in the front of the classroom. For Duncan it's politics that takes first priority.

Mr. Duncan says he favors getting to the root of the nation’s educational problems. Time magazine, for instance, quotes him as saying,
It’s obvious the [educational] system’s broken. Let’s admit it’s broken, let’s admit it’s dysfunctional, and let’s do something dramatically different, and let’s do it now. But don’t just tinker around the edges. Don’t just play with it. Let’s fix the thing.
The trouble is, at least when it comes to teacher education, Duncan doesn’t follow his own advice.

Letting State Officials Off the Hook

Duncan conveniently ignores the fact that state governments set, and enforce, standards for teacher education. So if programs are lousy, Duncan’s primary quarrel is with state officials.

Duncan could use the big bag of non-earmarked money that the Obama administration is injecting into schooling as a means to compel those officials to raise teacher education standards.

Would state officials do a good job of improving teacher education? Probably not, but since Duncan is inordinately fond of top-down reform, his inattention to state responsibility suggests he isn't really serious.

Professional Education Schools

Also, if Duncan were not just “tinkering around the edges,” but truly serious about improving teacher education, he would advocate the complete abolition of undergraduate programs. In their place, he would demand graduate-level professional schools of education modeled on the training required by other established professions.

Consider what is required of aspiring physicians, attorneys, architects, optometrists, dentists, podiatrists, veterinarians, and chiropractors, for example. Entrance into any of these occupations requires selective, tough, graduate-level schooling in a specialized environment. To qualify for entrance, candidates first have to grow up, get a college education, and pass a tough examination.

In contrast, teacher education programs typically are mere undergraduate majors that must compete for student attention with other undergraduate requirements and campus social life. Most teacher education programs can’t even select their own applicants. They must accept anyone the university admits who declares they want to major in education. In consequence, teacher educators have to make do with many immature, unfocused, often marginally committed youngsters who aren’t developmentally ready for serious study.

By what magic is such raw material to be transformed into skilled, dedicated professionals?

Money Talks
Why the enormous difference between training in the true professions and in teaching? Is teaching easy? Just give it a try. Is there little to learn? Not the last time I checked. No, the reason those other occupations can charge a higher price for admission is because of the generous benefits that await graduates.

Forgetting his secret tape recorder was on, Richard Nixon once candidly observed, “Money talks and bullshit walks.” And Secretary Duncan emphasizes that sort of bullshit in his speeches. He specializes in fertilizer such as this:

There is no question that our country needs you. Our children need you.
[I]f you care about promoting opportunity and reducing inequality, the classroom is the place to start.
Great teaching is about so much more than education; it is a daily fight for social justice.
This call to teaching is the great public mission of our time. . . .[3]


Secretary Duncan goes on to say, “Put plain and simple, this country needs an army of great, new teachers.”[5]

What Duncan does not say is that this country is not about to offer sufficient rewards for teaching to attract many of the best and brightest, nor will it support truly professional preparation. In fact, Duncan's florid rhetoric indicates that the substantial benefits of teaching are slim indeed. That doesn’t mean that the symbolic benefits are unworthy, mind you, but in this materialistic society they don’t offer the same degree of motivation as money.

Warm Bodies
Given how we poorly we reward teachers and how enthusiastically we dump on them, professionalizing entrance requirements would cause the candidate pool to dry up. Then where would we find the roughly two hundred thousand new teachers per year that the United States will shortly need? Remember, it has been a long time since sexism forced nearly all the best and brightest women into teaching. Today’s competent women have many other options.

Conclusion
The truth is that America's politicos only pretend that they want high-quality teacher preparation. If they really wanted it they would not tolerate slack state regulation, ever-easier ways to enter teaching, and exploitation by short-sighted college officials. It's just that, given the current costs and benefits of being a teacher, it is absolutely necessary to make it cheap and easy to enter the occupation.

Of course, this slapdash approach creates many difficulties. But they can be dealt with by focusing still more blame on teachers and teacher educators. Duncan’s rhetoric provides a perfect example of this political sleight of hand.

What lies beyond Duncan's rhetorical smokescreen? In the end, it is more of the same old bullshit. We might as well still have William Bennett in the saddle. At least he offered comic relief.

In the end one can’t help but wonder if the Secretary of Education would encourage his own kids to become teachers. A quote from William C. Bagley comes to mind:

When will men who would never for a moment encourage their own sons to enter the work of the public schools cease to tell us that education is the greatest and noblest of all human callings?[4]

To further examine these and similar issues, see articles at www.newfoundations.com

-- GKC

35 comments:

Anonymous said...

做愛偷拍影片做愛光碟做愛光諜做愛免費a片av做愛免費無碼a片做愛卡通做愛卡通線上看做愛卡漫做愛姿勢動畫做愛姿勢圖做愛姿勢持九做愛姿勢教學做愛姿勢書做愛姿式圖片做愛姿式大全做愛姿態做愛寫真做愛射精自拍做愛導覽做愛小影片做愛尿身上做愛幾次做愛影做愛影片做愛姿勢免費做愛姿勢示範做愛姿勢.做愛呻吟做愛圖做愛圖片做愛圖片網站做愛在對方陰部吐口水做愛地點做愛天堂做愛套餐做愛女優做愛女性準備做愛女上男下做愛女人做愛如何持久

Anonymous said...

我是天山,等待一輪明月。.........................

Anonymous said...

上床圖片av圖片免費色情圖台灣性網陰蒂淫妹貼圖色情激突成人論壇成人色情網激情成人聊天室情色影音鹹濕女生自慰影片淫慾自慰色情a片成人色情圖片網情人視訊網成人話題成人色情台灣成人淫蕩a圖片情色留言板女生奶頭情色成人全裸美女圖片情色寫真裸體照大奶子台灣色情成人網站一夜正妹美女裸體寫真g罩杯美女sex520情趣娃娃視訊打槍視訊辣妹uthome淫亂走光照av情色網女生高潮成人自拍火辣眉眉太太陰毛美女視訊聊天全裸入鏡火辣av三點全露

Anonymous said...

I love readding, and thanks for your artical...................................................

Anonymous said...

好問才能博學。........................................

Anonymous said...

Hello~Nice to meet you~..................................................

Anonymous said...

超駭人實錄!!
穿白色雨衣的女人
胎兒的怨恨
背包帶怎麼有紅色的...?
美國被襲-陰陽眼短
值班室遇鬼記

Anonymous said...

good~ keep sharing with us, please....I will waiting your up date everyday!! Have a nice day........................................

Anonymous said...

穿幫成人影音視訊辣妹情慾adult台灣情色情色視訊聊天室手淫挑逗性愛技巧成人聊天成人圖貼陰脣av成人網自慰影片視訊做愛g點女生自慰免費視訊聊天室陰蒂成人聊天色情照片台灣av色情聊天室限制級影片成人av裸體美女色情dvd色情貼片明星露點裙底風光美女視訊免費情色av成人淫叫作愛影片成人情色a片論壇成人資訊成人圖貼色情小說色情小說

Anonymous said...

一定要保持最佳狀況呦,加油!!!期待你發表的新文章!.............................................

Anonymous said...

君子立恆志,小人恆立志。.............................................

天光天光 said...

happy new year!!..................................................

KatheleenJ said...

xh美色網 免費a片下載嘟嘟情人色網影片 av,sex520免費影片 完全免費視訊聊天 777美女dvd辣妹視訊 免費視訊celia aio交友視訊愛情館 西門慶成人論壇 台中酒店S援交 sex888影片分享區高中生援交 一葉情貼影片區 1314視訊 情人線上aa片試看嘟嘟 情人視訊網a 妹妹視訊 情色網成人電影 xxxholic次元魔女 成人文學小弟弟貼影片區 亞亞成人館 ut成人聊天室 微風成人 go2av免費看影片 104黑色會美眉自慰 日本同志色教館情色文學成人小說 34c視訊辣妹美女sex888免費電影 情色視訊論壇 0204貼圖區免費色情電影 成人貼圖站 交友ggo 免費影片下載a gogo2sex日本 拓網交友視訊美女 080情人網伊利論壇 一本道 a片 東京熱免費成人影片觀賞 交友ggoo 夜未眠影片中心 34c情人視訊網 一夜情性 情色視訊 美女 亞洲禁果名模影城 日本av論壇 台南視訊34c美女館 bt論壇交友網成人情色視訊妹 免費情人視訊 性愛電影85cc 聊天室交友whei 38girl視訊美女 aa免費影片 獨秀視訊聊天室 av730美眉共國 辣妹哈啦聊天室

Anonymous said...

you two make a lovely couple............................................................

Anonymous said...

感覺很好的blog,祝你開心喔........................................

皇雯皇雯 said...

一沙一世界,一花一天堂,掌中握無限,剎那即永恆......................................................................

Anonymous said...

一棵樹除非在春天開了花,否則難望在秋天結果。.................................................................                           

Anonymous said...

一棵樹除非在春天開了花,否則難望在秋天結果。....................................................................

Anonymous said...

成熟,就是有能力適應生活中的模糊。.................................................................

Anonymous said...

人生是故事的創造與遺忘。............................................................

Anonymous said...

來拜訪你囉~期待你的下次文章~加油^^..................................................................

Anonymous said...

一個人就像一個分數,他的實際才能是分子,他對自己的評價是分母。分母越大,則分數的價值越小。..................................................

Anonymous said...

希望我的支持可以帶給你快樂--加油.............................................................

Anonymous said...

玩遊戲玩到累,還是逛逛文章休閒一下!!輕鬆自在最舒服~~..................................................................

Anonymous said...

絕不要羞於承認自己不知道的事。..................................................

Anonymous said...

多謝分享~ 真是意料之外的收獲!!............................................................

Anonymous said...

超棒的,給予最大支持。(* ̄△ ̄*)............................................................

曹初帆張武茜 said...

生命所經歷的折磨愈多,其所產生的奮鬥力愈大。............................................................

Anonymous said...

永遠支持你呀!!HO!!HO!!HO!!HO!!~~..................................................................

Anonymous said...

男女互悅,未必廝守終生,相愛就是美的。.................................................................

Anonymous said...

Better be the head of a dog than the tail of a lion.............................................................

Anonymous said...

Rome was not built in a day............................................................

Anonymous said...

喜歡自己的另一層意義是「接納自己」。..................................................

蔡曼鄭美玉屏 said...

時間可證明一切~你的BLOG是我覺得不賴的............................................................

Anonymous said...

跟您打聲招呼,願我們大家都更好!!..................................................................