Discussions of public
schooling are usually solemn but they seldom are serious. Most of what is
said is a stew of wishful thinking seasoned with a sprinkle of lies. So let’s
be novel and take a rational approach based on simple truths.
Let's begin by recognizing that people respond to incentives. When a behavior is rewarded, people do more of it, and more intensely. If behavior is costly, (Costly from their point of view, mind you. ) people do less of it.
Now, let’s consider grades. Some youngsters regard good grades as rewarding in and
of themselves. Others see them as valuable
because it pleases their parents. Still others see them as means to other ends, such as a scholarship or admission to a favorite school. And for many, it's all of the above. In any case, youngsters who regard grades as valuable, will work to achieve them.
But
some youngsters regard good grades as valueless. Sometimes, even undesirable. (Good grades might make them a target for their peers.) They see little or no connection between
what they get and any future they imagine for themselves. In addition, some parents couldn't care
less about their children’s grades. (Read Claude Brown’s biography, Man Child
in the Promised Land, for a sad, real life account.) So, given such situations, it makes more sense not to try and possibly raise some hell instead.
What rewards can a teacher offer that will make a student want to learn? Well, there is teacher praise. But that generally
appeals to kids who already care about grades. Alternatively, some teachers develop a
token economy. They buy, typically at their own expense, affordable things that most
kids would like to have. Then, using, say, poker chips, they establish and economy where those chips can be cashed in for prizes. That sometimes works, but it is
costly, requires book keeping and can be regarded as bribery.
An alternative is for teachers to make lack of effort, or outright opposition, prohibitively costly? That can be effective. Corporal
punishment was used that way for centuries. An ancient
Egyptian hieroglyphic even reads, “Learning comes with blood.” But modern
pedagogues are forbidden to use corporal punishment as motivation. In fact, the authorities would punish them.
So
what are teachers left with? In some cases, inner city schools for instance, a sizable, sometimes paralyzing, number of kids care less about grades. And they cannot be motivated by, or successfully threatened with, anything else. The net result is "students" who are impossible to teach because they lack
motivation. And that breeds all kinds of trouble.
What
it to be done? Not much. The present strategy seems to be just blame it on the
teachers. That’s wholly unfair, but not for politicians. For them it works pretty well.
For
articles related to this topic try the site search at www.newfoundations.com.
No comments:
Post a Comment